We serve our pies at room 
temperature, so you are welcome to keep them on a cool counter, out of direct heat. If you won't be serving your pies for a day or two, you can also keep them in the refrigerator (in the box is fine).
Our pies are best stored in the refrigerator and eaten within 2 days of purchase. However, they can be refrigerated for up to 5 days.

How long do your pies keep? What's the best way to store them?

pie care + instructions

While we do recommend eating our pies fresh and within a few days of purchasing, many of our pies are suitable for freezing.

​For proper freezing, tightly wrap the pie in plastic wrap twice. When you're ready to thaw, unwrap the pie and allow it to thaw in the refrigerator for 8 hours. See below for heating instructions.

Can I freeze my pie?

As a general rule, pies with meringue topping, chess pies, and custard pies are not recommended for serving warm (they will melt in the oven and won't hold their shape).

​To warm a fruit pie from the fridge, heat the oven to 350º F cover with foil and warm for 20 minutes, checking the pie by placing your hand over the center to see if it is fully warmed (more time may be required).

To warm your sweet pie straight from the freezer, heat the oven to 350º F and warm for 30 minutes, checking the pie by placing your hand over the center to see if it is fully warmed (more time may be required).
To warm your savory pie from frozen heat oven to 350F and bake for 90-120 minutes until the filling reaches a temp of 165 F.

Can my pie be reheated?

Let's make some (customized) magic!


weddings + catering

frequently asked questions

Our pies measure 9" in diameter, and typically serve 6 - 8 people.

What size are your pies? How many people does 1 pie serve?

No, due to the volume of orders we will not be able to include savory pies.

Will Savory Pies be Available for Purchase during Thanksgiving Week?

The cut off (last day) to pre-order pies for Thanksgiving Week is Friday, November 19th at 9:00 pm. After this time, no additional orders can be placed and there are no refunds, replacements or edits to your Thanksgiving Pie order, no exceptions. All pies MUST be pre-ordered since we are doing the Pie pick up at the Mix Kitchen on Wed Nov 24 only.

When is the Cut Off (the Last Day) to pre-order pies for Thanksgiving Week?

Yes. All pies must be paid for during the time they are ordered to confirm your order.

Am I required to prepay for my Thanksgiving Week Pie?

Due to the volume of orders we receive, we will only be doing pick up this year. There will not be delivery! Pick up for thanksgiving pies is Wed Nov 24 from 9-6 pm only. If you do not pick up your pie, it will be donated to the local homeless shelter.

What are the pick-up days and times for Thanksgiving Week Pies?

Sweet J’s products may contain or come in contact with dairy, wheat, soy, tree nuts, nuts, gluten and other allergens. People with food allergies or sensitivities are strongly advised against placing an order. We are not liable for any food allergies/sensitive related issues.

Do I need to be worried about any allergies?






For customized cakes, click here. For catering inquiries, click here.

Thank you!

Your message has been sent. We'll contact you shortly

Craving something more?